Project D04 - Some Sum!


In 1689 Jakob Bernoulli deduced that the series

¥
å
n = 1 
1
n2
converges to a real number less than two, but none of the mathematicians of the time could determine its exact value. It was not until 1734 that Leonhard Euler, a student of Johann Bernoulli (Jakob's brother), solved the problem. In this project, you will study Euler's approach to finding the exact sum of the series.


  1. Show that
    ¥
    å
    n = 1 
    2
    n(n+1)
    = 2.
    (Hint: Find a partial fraction decomposition and rewrite the series as a telescoping series.)
  2. By comparing terms, argue that
    ¥
    å
    n = 1 
    1
    n2
    < ¥
    å
    n = 1 
    2
    n(n+1)
    ,
    and thereby deduce that the first series converges to a number less than 2.
  3. (Enter Leonhard Euler) Find the power series, centered at x = 0, for f(x) = sin(x).
  4. Now consider the function F(x) = sin(x) / x and let's just say F(0) = 1 so that F is defined and continuous for all real numbers. Explain why we can say this.
  5. Use your power series for f to find a power series for F.
  6. Euler simply thought of the power series as an infinite polynomial. Since F(0) = 1 and F(kp) = 0 for any integer k, Euler concluded that
    F(x) = æ
    è
    1 - x
    p
    ö
    ø
    æ
    è
    1 - x
    -p
    ö
    ø
    æ
    è
    1 - x
    2p
    ö
    ø
    æ
    è
    1- x
    -2p
    ö
    ø
    ¼
    (1)
    Explain why this seems to make sense.
  7. Show that the equality above amounts to
    1 - x2
    3!
    + x4
    5!
    - x6
    7!
    + ¼ = æ
    è
    1 - x2
    p2
    ö
    ø
    æ
    è
    1 - x2
    4p2
    ö
    ø
    æ
    è
    1- x2
    9p2
    ö
    ø
    ¼
    (2)
  8. Now we'll focus on the term involving x2. First, on the left hand side of equation (2), notice that the coefficient of x2 is -1/6. Now for the right hand side! Let's use Mathematica to determine the coefficient of x2.
    1. We'll need to ``trick'' Mathematica so that it doesn't carry out certain computations. Enter a:={"1","2","3","4","5","6","7","8","9"} (We'll make Mathematica think these integers are text strings.)
    2. Enter b=Product[1-x^2/(Pi^2 a[[k]]^2), {k,1,9}]
    3. Find the coefficient of x2 in the product by entering c=Coefficient[b, x^2]
    4. Now simplify. Simplify[c]
    5. What series forms the coefficient of x2?
  9. Equate the coefficients of x2 on the left and right hand sides of (2). What is the sum of the series
    ¥
    å
    n = 1 
    1
    n2
    ?
  10. (Extra Credit) Evaluate F and the right hand side of (2) at x = p/2. Obtain an infinite product whose value is p/2.